Browse cases by category
- Attorneys & Legal Services
- Bankruptcy
- Civil Procedure & Administrative Law
- Civil Rights
- Consumer
- Criminal
- Disability
- Economic Development
- Education
- Elections
- Employment
- Environmental Justice
- Evidence
- Family Law
- Food Programs
- Government and Governmental Services
- Guardianship & Conservatorship
- Health
- Housing
- Immigration
- Juveniles
- License (Auto & Others)
- Mental Health
- Migrants
- Native Americans
- Other
- Prisons
- Public Utilities & Energy
- Rural Issues
- Senior Citizens
- Social Security & SSI
- Taxation
- Torts
- Unemployment Compensation & Unemployment Insurance
- Veterans & Military
- Welfare
- Wills & Estates
- Workforce Development
Clark v. Kizer
No. CIV S-87-1700 JFM (E.D. Cal. Apr. 6, 1993) ; Clearinghouse Number: 43105
Description
$1.2 Million Attorney Fees Awarded to Seven California Legal Services Programs in Statewide Class Action
Abstract
The court has awarded seven legal services programs a total of
$1,249,021 in attorney fees in this class action in which
plaintiffs successfully challenged California's failure to
comply with federal law in the administration of the maternity and
dental care programs under Medi-Cal. The court noted that
plaintiffs' attorneys expended over 5,000 hours of attorney
time and 925 hours of paralegal time on the four-year litigation,
and they produced excellent results for plaintiff class. The court
found counsel to have put together a team drawn from organizations
statewide that litigated a complex and difficult case efficiently
and with exceptional skill. In finding to be reasonable the number
of hours plaintiffs claimed, the court also held that plaintiffs
were entitled to include 12.94 hours spent at press conferences,
given the magnitude of this litigation and the public need to know.
The hourly rates that counsel requested, from $110 to $280 per hour
for attorneys and $75 per hour for law clerks and paralegals, were
well supported in the state market. Plaintiffs' counsel were
also to receive $16,379 for expenses, mostly for travel.
Additional Information
Files
- Plaintiffs' Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Motion for Preliminary Injunction
- Order (14pp.).
- Proposed Partial Consent Decree (19pp.)
- Plaintiffs' Request for Production of Documents From All Defendants
- Plaintiffs' Interrogatories to Defendants
- Plaintiffs' Request for Production of Documents From All Defendants (2nd Set)
- Plaintiffs' Interrogatories to Defendants (2nd Set)
- Plaintiffs' Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in support of their motion for Partial Summary Judgement
- Memo of points and authorities in support of the plaintiff's motion for Partial Summary Judgement
- Defendant's memo of points and authorities in support of the plaintiff's motion for Partial Summary Judgement
- Plaintiffs' memo in support of motion for Partial Summary Judgement
- Brief of Amicus Curiae Sec. of Health & Human Services
- Order (22pp.);
- Plaintiffs' Supplemental Brief Re Injunctive Relief (11pp.)
- Notice of Motion for Award of Reasonable Attorneys' fees and expenses
- Supplemental Exhibits in support of Motion for Attorneys' fees and expenses
- Supplemental Declarations in support of Motion for Attorneys' fees and expenses
- Reply memo of points and authorities in support of motion for attorneys' fees and expenses
